Skip to main content

The Trouble With Dave Smith

  On the issues, Dave & most agorists can find agreement 99 out of 100 times, but as libertarians we have a habit, a pastime - a duty even, to seek out & argue over the 1% of things we don’t agree on. In keeping with that tradition friends, I've got to tell you, when it comes to strategy, Dave Smith seriously fumbles the ball. The fundamental issue is that @comicdavesmith is interested in creating libertarians, whereas agorists are interested in creating liberty. Dave has a classic case of @perbylund ’s Savior Complex - the irrational desire of individualists to save the collective whole of society. There are lots of problems with this, but even if creating libertarians is a worthy goal, does that mean the Libertarian Party is the best vehicle to accomplish this task? Has anything the Libertarian Party ever done caused even a slight retreat of statism? Dave rightly points to his own success at spreading the message of liberty. It's true, no one - save Ron Paul or Tom

The Feather Thief

If you follow my snapchat you may remember me posting about The Feather Thief by Kirk Wallace Johnson. The book tells the story of a 22-year old American college student, Edwin Rist, who developed a talent for the lost art of tying exotic fishing flies at a young age. The most prized and appreciated fishing flies call for the feathers of rare, exotic birds. Unfortunately for the small community of fly-tyers, the import of exotic feathers has been banned by the illiterates infesting Congress since the signing of the CITES Treaty (Convention on International Trade of Endangered Species) in 1975.

Prior to this, as Johnson details, trade in exotic plumage was driven by the fashion trends of the 18th, 19th, and early 20th century. The inclusion of feathers in women’s attire was a status symbol, and the more exotic the bird, the higher status it indicated. Marie Antoinette, a fashion icon of the late 18th century, famously bore a diamond encrusted egret. Soon, it was all the rage and women everywhere adopted the style.

An entire Bird of Paradise mounted on a woman's hat (c.1900)

As the demand for exotic feathers increased, public opinion started to turn. In the late 19th century, people began to feel a sense of sympathy for the birds and a sense of responsibility for the dwindling numbers of whole species. The Lacey Act of 1900 prohibited interstate commerce of certain birds & 3 years later Teddy Roosevelt was setting aside large swaths of land in Florida to protect the egret. Congress took additional measures in the years to come, including the Underwood Tariff and the Migratory Bird Treaty Act, all culminating in the CITES signing.

All of this legislation had a predictable result. By banning the trade of exotic feathers, Congress was, in effect, putting a cap on supply. Since demand for feathers remained high and supply was suppressed, the price for these exotic animals skyrocketed.

Rist, who was an avid flute player, attended the Royal Academy of Music in London. Soon, he learned that the nearby British Museum of Natural History at Tring, was home to the world’s largest collection of well-preserved exotic birds. Incentivized by seductive market pressures brought to bear by the economically illiterate cockroaches in Washington, Rist began planning to rob the museum of its collection of exotic bird species.


The author speaks of the monetary loss to the state’s museum and the setback to the scientific community. The first argument can be disregarded outright, as the fictional entity masquerading as “the state” never had the right to exist in the first place, let alone, own property. The second argument holds that birds collected in previous centuries can be tested using new scientific methods to shed light on evolution. Fair enough, however, the state ought to have expected such an outcome when they decided to ban hunting and importation of exotic birds while simultaneously monopolizing the existing supply for themselves. As if their purposes were somehow more nobler than the fisherman.

Had private ownership of these species not been impeded, it’s likely farmers, induced by high prices, would have began breeding these birds, driving their numbers way up. The demand for quail & pheasant hunting ensures those animals won't be new entries on the endangered species list anytime soon, so why not apply the same logic to cotingas & Indian crows? It would also enrich a new generation of farmers & their families, just as quail and pheasant hunting has. The same concept was successful in rebuilding the elephant and rhino populations in Africa.

One night, Edwin climbed a fence and threw a rock through the Tring’s window. Soon, he was inside the building, stuffing Birds of Paradise, Blue Chatterers, Resplendent Quetzals, & Indian Crows into a suitcase. 

The Resplendent Quetzal, is listed as "Near-Threatened" because politicians can't 
understand concepts as simple as the tragedy of the commons. 

I won’t spoil the ending, in case you’d like to read the book. It’s well written and informative, and though it’s non-fiction, it sometimes takes on the feel of a thriller. For my part, I just wanted to point out how all of it - the flirtation that some species of birds have had with extinction & Rist’s heist, with all of it's consequences - is completely the state’s fault.

Note: If you're interested in learning more about free market environmentalism, check out this lecture by Walter Block.


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Dear America, I Won't Be Locking Down

Dear America I won’t be locking down, not that I ever did. And I don’t care about the arbitrary mandates of a geriatric pedophile with a history of dementia. I don’t wear the muzzle or social distance. Nor do I have any plans to start. I won’t be avoiding friends or family & I actively seek out large public gatherings. Needless to say, it’ll be a cold, cold day in hell before the government injects my living body with a foreign substance or keeps me from my family on Thanksgiving Day. You see, I knew from day one that COVID was a hoax. More specifically, when videos of Chinese people dropping dead in the streets were being broadcasted by Western propaganda outlets, it became clear this was essentially a soft coup. As a general rule, anything coming from the CCP should immediately be assumed to be intentionally falsified for malicious purposes. Friends, what has happened is obvious. The political cartel has manufactured a virus because fear enables them to seize power & furthers

Against the LP

Agorism has no room for politics.  The Agora & political institutions can coexist no more than a state of marriage & bachelorhood can coexist. Counter-economics & politicking are likewise mutually exclusive. Frankly, it should seem obvious that engaging in politics & anti-politics is contradictory & self-defeating. It wouldn’t make much sense to get chemo in the morning & smoke a pack of Marlboros in the evening, so why would one seek to destroy the government today, and empower it tomorrow?  Just as a chemist who tests a logically inconsistent theory will experience failure, so too will social scientists & revolutionaries experience failure when they pursue inconsistent theories.  Note that without exception - every gain made by the liberty community in the past 15 years has been produced by the counter-economy & that no other faction of our movement can claim even a small victory . Here’s a brief look at the scoreboard: Whereas the LP & small gov

In Defense of Left Libertarianism

Marx was right, but Marxism is stupid. Let me explain… Marx’s fundamental critique that the working class is being exploited by the upper class is true. This is so inherently obvious in the modern political climate that I find it bewildering the notion even needs defending. In fact, today, the working class has been so thoroughly exploited that they can now be more accurately termed the working poor . Go to Manhattan, the neoliberal shithole from whence I came - and try to find a worker who both lives & resides there. You can’t. There aren’t any. The elites have successfully used a combination of high taxes & a denial of civil liberties to expel the working class from their homes. Trust me, I am among the expelled. The anarcho-capitalist habit of turning a blind eye to class theory is a grave mistake, as it sweeps real concerns under the rug. In doing so they dismiss the plight of an enormous contingent of the public - labor. No, we agorists aren’t seeking an abandonment of met