Skip to main content

Becoming Your Own Bank: Bitcoin for Beginners

Traditionally, in order to successfully exchange goods with an individual or firm not physically present, one must utilize a third party. With online shopping, the most obvious example - this third party usually takes the form of a credit card company, bank, or other payment processor such as PayPal. This third party is neither a buyer nor a seller. In the context of the exchange, the third party's sole function is to verify both the transmission & receipt of funds. For this service, they will of course collect a small fee.

Unfortunately, our enemy, the state, has discovered that by exercising control over a small number of the most popular third parties, they can succesfully interject themselves into our financial affairs. Thus, banks are used to rob us via inflation. Taxes are extorted at the point of sale. Black market products are prohibited from exchange. Etcetera.

The advent of Bitcoin in 2008 provided sufficient disintermediation to alleviate all of these concerns entir…

The Economics of BTC Maximalism





BTC maximalism is a flawed doctrine, fallacious in numerous respects. 

First, if you'd prefer to hear these arguments in audio, check out this recent episode of ABNP, where @mrpseu & I discused these same topics. 

Also, a qualifier: I'm not capable of making, defending or refuting technical arguments. I'll leave that aspect of the debate to others. My concerns with BTC maximalism are entirely economic and can be divided into four areas. 


  1. Based on the criteria for saleability as laid out by the austrian school, BTC is not the most marketable digital commodity.
  2. A lack of portability relative to other cryptocurrencies implies BTC isn't as sound of a commodity. 
  3. Value storage is a secondary function of money and cannot satisfy the use-value requirement of regression theorem. 
  4. BTC maximalism lays waste to the Hayekian notion of competition as a discovery procedure. This final point was addressed in detail on episode 50 of The Agora, Crypto-Economics and thus, isn't elaborated on in great detail here.


Saleability


In order to understand the concept of saleability, consider the following example.

Imagine a barter economy, where commodities are directly exchanged one for another.

Alice is in possession of telescopes and wishes to trade one of them for some of the wheat that Bob has been growing on his farm. 1 telescope for 1 lb. of wheat seems like a fair deal, so Bob accepts the offer.

Next month Alice returns with another telescope seeking a repeat of the same trade. What should Bob do? He already has a perfectly good telescope, and certainly doesn’t need two.

Bob politely informs Alice that although he has no utility for a telescope, he could use a pair of shoes. Alice takes her wares to the local shoe shop and is politely denied by the cobbler who himself is in need of a plow - not astronomical instruments. Somewhat frustrated, she makes her way to the blacksmith who accepts the offer: 1 telescope for 1 plow. The plow can in turn be traded for the shoes, and the shoes in exchange for the wheat.

While leaving Bob’s grain farm, Alice notices that she isn’t the only one present hoping to trade for wheat. In fact, she notices much more economic activity on Bob’s wheat farm than in her telescope factory. This is because grain is a much more saleable, or marketable commodity.


Realizing everyone is willing to trade for wheat, Alice decides it’d be prudent to keep some additional wheat in reserve, beyond the amount she can personally consume. This way she can avoid the hassle of making a series of exchanges. Notice that the demand to hold a commodity in reserve is dependent upon its ability to function as a medium of exchange. In other words, if market participants are unwilling to use it as exchange media, there’s no reason for Alice to hold it in reserves in the first place.



“The functions of money as a transmitter of value thru time & space may be directly traced back to its function as a medium of exchange.” -LvM

A unified monetary system, given enough time will tend to prefer one or at most, a very small number of commodities as media of exchange.

As Mises explained:
“The greater the marketability of the goods first acquired in indirect exchange, the greater would be the prospect of being able to reach the ultimate objective without further maneuvering. Thus there would be an inevitable tendency for the less marketable of the series of goods used as media of exchange to be one by one rejected until at last only a single commodity remained, which was universally employed as a medium of exchange; in a word, money.”
 The question then becomes: what determines saleability?

Thankfully, Carl Menger gave us a very specific list of criteria to consider when evaluating the saleability of commodities through space, and also thru time. While I recommend everyone read Menger’s criteria for themselves here, for our purposes I’ve selected only the aspects which I believe constrain BTC’s chances of becoming money.


Carl Menger, 1840-1921

First, according to Menger, one aspect of spatial saleability is “the cost of transport incurred in proportion to it’s value.” If the cost of moving a digital commodity (aka transaction fee) is greater for Coin A than it is for Coin B, then in respect to this aspect of saleability - Coin B has the advantage. Being notorious for high transaction fees, BTC is at best, lackluster in this regard. Remember, only the most saleable commodity can become money.

Perhaps lightning will alleviate this, perhaps not. In the meantime, there are undeniably a host of digital commodities which already function efficiently in this regard.

Secondly, with respect to the temporal limits of saleability, of particular concern are “the restrictions imposed politically & socially on their being transferred from one period of time to another.” Thus, if states decide to prohibit, or merely threaten to prohibit the possession of cryptocurrencies, they can seriously damage their marketability. Therefore, as states like India, China & the US begin to crackdown, we can expect to see a decrease in the saleability of pseudonymous chains relative to anonymous chains.


Finally, as we’ve seen, saleability is a dynamic and not a static concept. It’s subject to change based on uncontrollable factors such as the behavior of third parties, like states. There is no way for maximalists to know whether or not BTC will satisfy market conditions, if those conditions don’t exist yet. For more on the Hayekian objections to BTC maximalism, check out this episode of The Agora with Jeffrey Tucker.

Soundness


On page 5 of The Bitcoin Standard, Saifedean Ammous says that the stock-to-flow ratio is a reliable indicator of a money’s hardness. However, stock-to-flow is only a measure of the relative abundance or scarcity of a given commodity - and scarcity, is but one element of soundness. By no means is it the only or exclusive component of sound money.

Sound money is indeed scarce. But it’s also homegenous, divisible, durable & crucially, portable. In the context of sound money, portability refers to a commodity's value-to-weight ratio. Gold is more portable than iron because if you wanted to purchase a car, you’d only need a pocketful of coins rather than a wagon full of iron. In other words, transporting gold requires less resources than transporting iron. Similarly, due to higher transaction fees, transporting BTC requires more resources than other cryptocurrencies.

Therefore, not only is BTC less saleable, but it’s also less sound.

Regression Theorem


The maximalist claim that BTC satisfies the use-value requirement of regression theorem by being a store of value is particularly simple to refute. This is mainly due to the fact that Menger & Mises expressly attacked the claim that money's primary function could be it's role as a store of value.


As they explain in great detail, all functions of money are secondary to its ability to function as a medium of exchange. Recall from our previous example that Alice only decided to use wheat as a store of value upon realizing it’s usefulness as a medium of exchange. This of course is only logical. Indeed, the reason most individuals continue to use fiat as a SoV and not gold - despite the latter’s better performance in this regard - is to ensure their funds are readily accessible in case they have to  suddenly be exchanged for goods or services.

As Menger explains in Principles of Economics:
"The portion of his wealth that an economizing individual intends to use for purchasing consumption goods attains that form in which he may, at any time, satisfy his needs in the most certain and most rapid manner if it is first exchanged for money."

He continues, more direct -
“...it appears to me to be just as certain that the functions of being a “measure of value” and a “store of value” must not be attributed to money as such, since these functions are of a merely accidental nature and are not an essential part of the concept of money.”

 Chapter 1 of Mises' later work, Theory of Money and Credit, devoted an entire section to the "Secondary Functions" of money, which included value storage. In fact, Mises' tone towards those who mistook these secondary functions of money for it's primary purpose was borderline mockery - and is frankly as appropriate today, as it was when it was written in 1912.
"After Menger's review of the question, further discussion of the connection between the secondary functions of money and its basic function should be unnecessary. Nevertheless, certain tendencies in recent literature on money make it appear advisable to examine briefly these secondary functions - some of them are coordinated with the basic function by many writers - and to show once more that all of them can be deduced from the function of money as common medium of exchange."
So, if Bitcoin’s primary utility cannot logically be value storage then what is it’s use-value? Bitcoin’s initial utility was the enabling of p2p transactions without the need for third party intermediaries. In other words, to bank the unbanked. 


Prior to the advent of Bitcoin, if my friend and TNL contributor, Alex Utopium (Norway), and I (NYC) wished to conduct a transaction, we’d need a third party, such as VISA, or a bank, to verify that one of us had sent the funds & also that the other had received them. Naturally, this systematic centralization became a magnet for political parasites to infiltrate the financial sovereignty of individuals. Satoshi’s white paper changed this forever. Ever since and forever more, any two people, anywhere in the world, can transact without statists prying into their affairs.

For a real world example, look no further than the agorist hero, Ross Ulbricht. Inspired by the late J. Neil Schulman's Alongside Night, Ross created the first truly free and uncensored market humanity has ever known. Without a p2p currency, the Silk Road would have never been possible, but with it, buyers & sellers were able to transact without worrying about third party censorship. 

This is the utility of Bitcoin.

Final Thoughts


In conclusion, based on the Austrian criteria for saleability, BTC has two weaknesses. First, it’s marketability thru space is limited by transaction fees. Also, the pseudonymous nature of BTC leaves the chain vulnerable to state interference and limits it’s temporal saleability relative to anonymous chains. Secondly, transporting BTC currently requires more resources than a host of other digital commodities, making it less portable, and thus, less sound. Finally, the maximalist claim that BTC satisfies the utility requirement of regression theorem as a means of value storage suffers from circularity. Value storage is a secondary function of money dependent on it's ability to serve it's primary function as exchange media. 

Do you agree or disagree? Share your thoughts in the comments below!







Comments

  1. Good article.

    BTC is indeed inferior to some other cryptos when it comes to high transaction costs, but it is superior when it comes to security, thanks to its very high share of mining hash power. Personally I don't think BTC can take its hash power for granted indefinitely, and must eventually compete on transaction costs and things like anonymity. But this article would be more balanced and insightful if it acknowledged this current BTC strength and opined on what BTC would have to do to maintain this strength relative to other cryptos.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Good money is fungible. Bitcoin is not fungible. Monero is fungible. GetMonero DotOrg

    ReplyDelete
  3. Your blog is very useful for us and i love your topic mentioned in blog.

    Thank you

    altcoin haberleri

    ReplyDelete
  4. Oni #Token's aims to become the key protocol for #Trading AI and investment learning tools to form a coordinated Artificial General Intelligence.
    To accomplish this, the Oni Token is powered as a utility token that is tailored to enabling its core functionality. The Oni token is structured to enable four key mechanisms: #Investment, #Mining, #Artificial #Intelligence and Trading Services.
    #Oni #Token represents a very interesting class of investment options that offers 10 to 20 percent return on investment. The concept and mechanism is the gateway for more general tokenized equities. The distinctive feature of Oni token represents real infrastructure projects, making them a safer investment option for institutional and traditional investors.

    Website : https://oni.fund/
    Facebook: https://web.facebook.com/TheOniToken?_rdc=1&_rdr
    Telegram: https://t.me/OniToken
    Twitter: https://twitter.com/OniToken
    Whitepaper: https://oni.fund/Whitepaper.pdf
    Medium: https://medium.com/@OniToken

    ReplyDelete
  5. FOR IMMEDIATE ONLINE RELEASE - Today the Templar Fund, a publicly
    transparent Bitcoin Hedge Fund announced that after 272 days of continuous trading,
    they have achieved a compounded return on equity of 50.002% for its clients.

    Every $100 invested on November 21, 2018 is now worth $150.02.

    The Templar Fund is a privately-managed Bitcoin Hedge fund that publishes the
    entirety of its trade records for public consumption and audit, as well as comprehensive
    fund performance reports every 10 days.

    The Templar Fund welcomes clients from any jurisdiction, as it is not subject to FATCA
    or reporting requirements. To protect their anonymity & account security, clients only
    need to provide an e-mail address to create an account.

    For more information and to download the comprehensive report of the trade cycle
    detailed in this release visit: https://templar.fund/

    ReplyDelete
  6. Buy Make Money Great Again Snapback Hat
    Buy M.M.G.A Bitcoin Unisex Hoodie Bitcoin Unisex Hoodie
    Buy Crypto Trinity Hoody
    Buy We are Satoshi old School Bucket Hat
    To see more proiduct visit https://hodlsociety.com/

    ReplyDelete
  7. Fydcoin is a cryptocurrency for the gig economy. With staking and masternodes and a decentralized marketplace for freelancers
    Website: https://www.fydcoin.com/
    Twitter: https://twitter.com/FydcoinO
    Facebook: https://m.facebook.com/FYDcoin
    Linkedin: https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/fyd-coin-cryptocurrency-gig-economy-fyd-coin?trk=portfolio_article-card_title

    #Freelancers #Crypto #Bitcoin #masternodes #Blockchain No #ICO

    ReplyDelete
  8. Lionswealth is a consortium of consultants who have already successfully placed various blockchain-based projects on the market. We know the potential of this revolutionary technology and apply our knowledge to your benefit. With our know-how we constantly set new standards and always get the best out of your idea.
    We realize our visions with our strong partners and therefore offer you everything you need for a successful market entry.
    Check http://bit.ly/2ANlLMd for more info

    ReplyDelete
  9. Free 9000 KW/H Bonus !
    Sign up now and start making money, get an additional
    1000 KW/h when you use a referral code.
    http://bit.ly/2IvCWGx

    ReplyDelete
  10. Next-Generation
    Cryptocurrency Exchange
    Buy, Sell, and Spend at https://www.coinzoom.com/
    Join telegram : https://t.me/coinzoomcommunity
    Twitter : https://twitter.com/GetCoinZoom
    Get Early Access: https://www.coinzoom.com/early-access/

    #crypto #ico #bitcoin #btc #investment #makemoney #coin

    ReplyDelete
  11. #FXBK is a #token that was created for the purpose of enabling individuals to participate and profit in the Forex Market through trading. The proceeds of the sale of the #tokens, will go into a trading account which will be traded using #Algorithms that have been developed in house. Then 50% of the profits will be used to buy back the coin on the open market at the offer price from the exchange that we will list on. Hence the name FX buy back.

    Website : https://fxbuyback.com/
    Facebook : https://www.facebook.com/FX-Algo-Trading-100378488041548/
    Twitter : https://twitter.com/tradingcurrenc7
    Youtube : https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCYKLPIM4R8nvbESvaJdWzMQ
    Telegram : https://t.me/fxalgotrading
    Bitcointalk : https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=5191594.0

    ReplyDelete
  12. Coenx is a hybrid #Advertising and Reward platform with a discounted #Crypto #Exchange at a lowest fee of 0.03 percent. Join Coenx to View ads and Earn #Crypto.
    https://www.coenx.com/

    And Earn Crypto in 1 2 3 Steps..
    at : https://bitcoin.dotcompal.co/Coenx-AB

    ReplyDelete
  13. Ritcoin the art of cryptocurrency,
    Get crypto news including #trending cryptos, #bitcoin (btc), #ethereum (eth), #litecoin (ltc), ripple (xrp), cardano (ada) news, bitcoin cash (bch), verge (xvg) tron (trx) news, crypto mining, hashflare – cloud mining, genesis cloud #mining review, giga watt – mining solution review, buy/sell, quadrigacx, make cryptos, free crypto ebook and more at : http://ritcoin.Co/

    ReplyDelete
  14. Buy or sell #Bitcoin, #Ripple and #Litecoin with ease. Trade with people around you in your local #currency. Try Koinsvendors now
    at : http://www.koinvendors.com/

    ReplyDelete
  15. Sign up now for 1,000 FREE credits! Dont forget to check out the awesome affiliate program!
    https://onecryptocasino.com?ref=2

    ReplyDelete
  16. Autonomous Infrastructure & Quantum Laser Communications
    Space Based Ecosytem™
    Quantum Mesh Network™
    QSAT™ Blockchain Satellites and StealthCrypto® Ground
    Mesh Network. Creating QG™ Quantum Generation™.
    Transforming our global infrastructure
    http://quantumgeneration.io/

    Space based exchange : http://qexchange.ai/
    Space-based bank : http://quantumbank.ai/
    Satellite sit : http://qsat.ai/

    ReplyDelete
  17. Hey crypto miners fans! CLOSING SALE! 50% OFF! Innosilicon G32 500, Obelisk SC1 Immersion, StrongU STU-U6, Antminer S17 Pro 53TH and much more!
    http://shopminersonline.com

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Global Warming & Economics

Libertarians who deny the existence of global warming run the risk of making us all look like a bunch of illiterate fools.

Much like economics, being ignorant of planetology or climate science isn't a crime, but having a "loud and vociferous" opinion on the subject while remaining in a state of ignorance can be a dangerous thing. And frankly, the science behind climate change is elementary.

Sunlight enters our atmosphere and warms our planet. Earth then gives off that heat in the form of infrared radiation (this is the same principle behind those cool goggles our collapsitarian friends have). However, and this is a crucial point - the CO₂ molecules in our atmosphere do not allow IR to easily escape back into space. This is known as the greenhouse effect. As the temperature of the planet increases, polar ice caps melt and eventually surface water will begin to evaporate. Since H₂0 also prevents IR from escaping our atmosphere, the additional water vapor only compounds th…

Don't Vote for Alex

It is 2019 and in Norway, that means county and city-election year. You can vote for me, but this article is all about why you really shouldn't. [1] There are several ways to say 'No'. This is a story about the time I said 'Yes', what I will stay positive to and what I will be negative toward. 

"But it is immoral to support politicians to oppress us because they might relieve us one oppression" - Samuel Edward Konkin III


First of all, there is some explaining to do: In my last article on the New Libertarian I argued that party politics is a waste of time and that you could use that time more productive so this entire piece seems like its contradicting that one. It might, that is up to you to judge for yourself (and if you want a chat I'm very approachable on Twitter), but in my defense, I will highlight two things:

One: I'm not against solution-finding, culture-building or exchange of ideas. I can give no brighter example of this happening than the…